Comparing Cognitive Behavioral Therapy with Pharmacotherapy for major depressive disorder
Official title: Personalized Indications for CBT and Antidepressants in Treating Depression
Personalized Indications for Cognitive Behavioural Therapy and Antidepressants in the Treatment of Major Depressive Disorder and Persistent Depressive Disorder
Interventions
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy
CBT will be delivered in a one-to-one face-to-face format by trained Masters or PhD level CBT therapists who will follow a protocol adapted from existing manuals and piloted in the participating centres. Up to 20 sessions will be offered over 18 weeks, initially twice per week, then weekly and later spaced to every other week. The treatment will have core obligatory modules and flexible elements adaptable to participant's maintaining factors.
Pharmacotherapy
Pharmacotherapy will be prescribed and adjusted by psychiatrists in 20-30 minute pharmacotherapy sessions once every two weeks. The manual-guided best-evidence pharmacotherapy will follow current guidelines for first, second and third line treatment.41 The primary focus will be on serotonin-reuptake inhibiting antidepressant (escitalopram 5-20mg, sertraline 50-200 mg daily) monotherapy, which may remain the only treatment for the majority of participants. Augmentation (aripiprazole 2-10mg, bupropione 150-450mg) will be offered to participants with partial response. The manual, developed as part of Canadian Biomarker Integration Network in Depression (CAN-BIND).43, also specifies admissible supportive therapeutic elements and prohibits CBT-specific techniques.
Canadian Sites (1)
Nova Scotia Health Authority
Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada
Eligibility Criteria
See who this study is looking for17 criteria
The trial’s own eligibility text, word for word from the registry. Only the trial site can say who takes part.
Inclusion
- +a diagnosis of MDD or PDD established with the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-5 (SCID-5), and depression being the primary problem requiring clinical attention (judgement of intake clinician).
- +a minimum current severity of 14 on the 17-item Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression (HRSD-17)
- +a cumulative duration of depression of at least two months (this will exclude short-lasting first depressive episodes that do not require treatment of this intensity), age 18 or more (no upper limit)
- +capacity to provide informed consentInformed consentThe process of being told what taking part involves, then choosing freely.Read more →.
- +Exclusion CriteriaExclusion criteriaThe things that would prevent someone from taking part.Read more →
- +lifetime diagnosis of bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, schizophreniform disorder, schizoaffective disorder, or current alcohol or drug use disorder
- +recent receipt of adequate trial of psychological treatment (10 or more sessions in the past 12 months)
- +recently introduced antidepressant medication (new antidepressant in past 12 weeks or dose increase in the past 6 weeks)
- +previous non-response to two or more of study medications
- +acute suicide risk (MADRS suicide item≥4)
- +current psychotic symptoms.
Exclusion
- −lifetime diagnosis of bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, schizophreniform disorder, schizoaffective disorder, or current alcohol or drug use disorder
- −recent receipt of adequate trial of psychological treatment (10 or more sessions in the past 12 months)
- −recently introduced antidepressant medication (new antidepressant in past 12 weeks or dose increase in the past 6 weeks)
- −previous non-response to two or more of study medications
- −acute suicide risk (MADRS suicide item≥4)
- −current psychotic symptoms.
In plain language
Assembled directly from this trial’s registry record. Every sentence traces to a field below — nothing here is generated or interpreted.
What this study is
This study is testing a treatment for a condition.
Phase 4Phase 4A study of a treatment that is already approved and in use.Read more → — a study of a treatment already approved for use, following it in everyday practice.
What is being given or done in this study: Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, Pharmacotherapy.
From the trial registry
Built from these fields:
- designModule.designInfo.primaryPurpose
- designModule.phases
- armsInterventionsModule.interventions[].name
How the study is run
Which group you would be placed in is decided by chance, like a coin flip — not by you and not by your doctor.
This study is open-labelOpen-labelEveryone knows which treatment is being given — nothing is hidden.Read more →: everyone knows which treatment is being given, including you and the study team.
From the trial registry
Built from these fields:
- designModule.designInfo.allocation
- designModule.designInfo.maskingInfo.masking
Is there a placebo?
This study does not list a placeboPlaceboA dummy treatment with no active medicine, used for comparison.Read more → group.
There are 2 groups in this study.
From the trial registry
Built from this field:
- armsInterventionsModule.armGroups[].type
Who the study is looking for
The study lists a minimum age of 18 years, with no upper limit given.
The study is open to people of any sex.
The study does not accept healthy volunteersHealthy volunteerSomeone without the condition being studied who takes part anyway.Read more →.
These are the criteria the study lists. Only the trial siteTrial siteA hospital or clinic where a study is actually run.Read more → can decide whether someone can take part.
From the trial registry
Built from these fields:
- eligibilityModule.minimumAge
- eligibilityModule.sex
- eligibilityModule.healthyVolunteers
How big and how long
The study aims to enrol about 80 people.
The study is currently expected to finish around June 2027.
The main measurement is taken over: 2-52 weeks.
From the trial registry
Built from these fields:
- designModule.enrollmentInfo.count
- statusModule.completionDateStruct.date
- outcomesModule.primaryOutcomes[].timeFrame
What the study measures
Total score on the Montgomery Asberg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS) — measured over 2-52 weeks.
From the trial registry
Built from these fields:
- outcomesModule.primaryOutcomes[].measure
- outcomesModule.primaryOutcomes[].timeFrame
Source: NCT02752542 on ClinicalTrials.gov. The full registry text is further down this page — this summary never replaces it.
Not medical advice. What do these terms mean?
What is being tested — in plain terms
About Cognitive Behavioral TherapyBehavioural
CBT will be delivered in a one-to-one face-to-face format by trained Masters or PhD level CBT therapists who will follow a protocol adapted from existing manuals and piloted in the participating centres. Up to 20 sessions will be offered over 18 weeks, initially twice per week, then weekly and later spaced to every other week. The treatment will have core obligatory modules and flexible elements adaptable to participant's maintaining factors.
From the trial registry — its own words, unedited.
What a behavioural is here: A programme, therapy, education, or lifestyle approach being studied.
Read the full explanation → · in clinical review
About PharmacotherapyDrug
Pharmacotherapy will be prescribed and adjusted by psychiatrists in 20-30 minute pharmacotherapy sessions once every two weeks. The manual-guided best-evidence pharmacotherapy will follow current guidelines for first, second and third line treatment.41 The primary focus will be on serotonin-reuptake inhibiting antidepressant (escitalopram 5-20mg, sertraline 50-200 mg daily) monotherapy, which may remain the only treatment for the majority of participants. Augmentation (aripiprazole 2-10mg, bupropione 150-450mg) will be offered to participants with partial response. The manual, developed as part of Canadian Biomarker Integration Network in Depression (CAN-BIND).43, also specifies admissible supportive therapeutic elements and prohibits CBT-specific techniques.
From the trial registry — its own words, unedited.
What a drug is here: A medicine — a chemical or small-molecule treatment — given as the thing being studied.
Read the full explanation → · in clinical review
Common questions
Answered from this trial’s registry record. Where the record doesn’t say, these answers say so rather than filling the gap.
Am I eligible for this trial?
Only the trial siteTrial siteA hospital or clinic where a study is actually run.Read more → can decide whether someone can take part. Concord cannot make that determination, and neither can any tool that has not examined you.
What the study lists: a minimum age of 18 years.
The full inclusionInclusion criteriaThe things you must have or be for a study to consider you.Read more → and exclusion criteriaExclusion criteriaThe things that would prevent someone from taking part.Read more → are published on this page, exactly as the study team wrote them.
The useful next step is to bring this trial to your doctor. Answering a few questions first gives them something concrete to review.
From the trial registry
- eligibilityModule.minimumAge
- eligibilityModule.eligibilityCriteria
Is there a placebo?
This study does not list a placeboPlaceboA dummy treatment with no active medicine, used for comparison.Read more → group.
From the trial registry
- armsInterventionsModule.armGroups[].type
Would I know which treatment I am getting?
This study is open-labelOpen-labelEveryone knows which treatment is being given — nothing is hidden.Read more →: everyone knows which treatment is being given, including you and the study team.
Which group you would be placed in is decided by chance, like a coin flip — not by you and not by your doctor.
From the trial registry
- designModule.designInfo.maskingInfo.masking
- designModule.designInfo.allocation
Who can join?
The study lists a minimum age of 18 years, with no upper limit given.
It is open to people of any sex.
It does not accept healthy volunteersHealthy volunteerSomeone without the condition being studied who takes part anyway.Read more →.
Only the trial siteTrial siteA hospital or clinic where a study is actually run.Read more → can confirm whether a particular person can take part.
From the trial registry
- eligibilityModule.minimumAge
- eligibilityModule.sex
- eligibilityModule.healthyVolunteers
How long would this take?
The study's main measurement is taken over: 2-52 weeks.
The study as a whole is currently expected to finish around 2027-06.
How long any one person takes part can differ from the study length. The study team can tell you what the schedule looks like in practice.
From the trial registry
- outcomesModule.primaryOutcomes[].timeFrame
- statusModule.completionDateStruct.date
How many people are taking part?
The study aims to enrol about 80 people.
From the trial registry
- designModule.enrollmentInfo.count
Where is this happening?
This study lists one location: Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada.
Sites can open and close during a study, so confirm with the team before travelling.
From the trial registry
- trial_locations
About This Trial
Depression currently affects close to 2 million Canadians and is the leading cause of disability worldwide. Pharmacological treatments (antidepressant medication) and psychological treatments such as cognitive-behavioural therapy are available for depression, but the majority of those who receive treatment have an unsatisfactory response. On average, the combination of pharmacological and psychological treatment achieves better results than either treatment alone. However, the apparently superior results of combination treatment may be due to the fact that different individuals preferentially respond to pharmacological or psychological treatment. The invesitagtors have discovered several clinical factors and biomarkers that predict poor response to commonly used antidepressant medication: history of childhood maltreatment, loss of interest and reduced activity, a biomarker of systemic inflammation, and a genetic marker of sensitivity to environment. Indirect evidence suggests that the same factors may indicate the need for psychological treatment, but their usefulness as differential predictors of psychological and pharmacological treatment outcomes remains to be established. The investigators will test the hypothesis that a pre-determined clinical variables (history of childhood maltreatment, loss of interest and reduced activity) and biomarkers (serum C-reactive protein, a marker of systemic inflammation, and insulin resistence, an indicator of metabolic health) differentially predict response to antidepressants and to cognitive-behavioural psychotherapy with clinically significant accuracy. If this hypothesis is supported, the resulting predictor will allow personalized selection of treatment for depression, leading to improved outcomes and healthcare efficiency. Additional objectives include replication of additional predictors and integrative analyses aimed at refining the treatment choice algorithms.
Worth passing on?
Save it to the Care Package and send it to them, or to their doctor, in one message. Whether they follow it up is theirs to decide.
Review the Care PackageThis page is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Clinical trial eligibility can only be determined by the trial site after proper screening. Trial information is sourced from ClinicalTrials.gov and may not reflect the most current status. Always consult your healthcare provider before making decisions about clinical trial participation.